It's just OK.
Well, I should start by saying I'm no real fan of NY style pizza to begin with, with only a few exceptions (like Bronx Pizza in San Diego). I prefer a thin and crunchy crust, deep dish or sicilian style...just never got off much on the hand tossed thing. To me the most aweful pizza crust is one that is chewy and tough, and it seems lots of NY style pizza has that going on.
For what it is, I would say Anthony's is just OK. It's pretty greasy for my taste, but overall has a decent flavor. I wish they would cook the pizza slices more thoroughly. The garlic cheese bread is so skimpy on the cheese that you can actually see the individual melted shreds. The pizza slices have a lot of exposed crust with no sauce or cheese, which I find annoying. They have no unsweetened beverages, so you better like HFCS. On a brighter note, usually the staff is pretty friendly.
If you are a fan of NY style pizza, you might like it, but I have certainly had better.
Great Food, Mixed Service.
The pizza here is great, New York style pizza. Although, all of the cashiers have always been nice to me and the food at this location is as good as the one downtown and better than the one in Arvada, I often drive out of my way to Arvada to avoid the loud music and kitchen staff and for nicer ambience and decor.
Locally owned pie purveyor serves up basic, budget-friendly pizzas and pastas.. In Short Local customers come here for standard-issue pizza. Clean booths and tables, walk-up counter service, self-serve drinks and plastic flatware. Pizzas come in thin- and thick-crust versions. Both are the fold-it-in-half, grease-dripping type so popular in the Big Apple. The eatery also serves up affordable plates of pasta, fresh Italian-style salads and daily specials that include calzones. Delivery can take over an hour, but the wait's usually worth it.