(303) 233-3132

2255 Sheridan Blvd
Edgewater, CO 80214 39.75 -105.0533

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Edgewater

Reviews & Ratings for Sisters Pizza and Mussels

3 Star Rating: Average

20 reviews

What users are saying:

1 Star Rating: Poor

03/20/08

Possibly the Worst Pizza Joint in the World

by im4phil at Citysearch

Who owns this place? Is someone actually in charge?

I have never been to a more poorly run place in my life. The atmosphere seems like a chain restaurant but the chain would never let a place be run into the ground like this. While I was there I saw two people walk out before eating while another got into an arguement with the staff.

You might want to visit just for the comedy value.

  • Pros: I think they have food
  • Cons: Service, employees
1 Star Rating: Poor

08/17/09

Bye! Bye!

by smetlogik at Citysearch

Well, they are officially no longer in business.

  • Pros: They are out of business
  • Cons: none
1 Star Rating: Poor

07/14/09

Horrible Service, Disappointed

by pizzareview at Citysearch

We have had three terrible experiences with Sister’s. The first one I thought was a fluke, the second one we decided to never order from them again until suckered by the sign that read “New Management (for real this time)”. Needless to say, three strikes and we are done with second chances. For years Sister's has delivered pizza to our house, which happens to be just outside the delivery zone, but the store had always come through for us. So in hopes that the sign would deliver, we ordered our regular large pizza and a two liter, only to wait the hour and to be called by the store saying that the delivery driver did not want to make the entire trip to our house because of our location. He had the pizza in the car and refused to drive the extra two blocks, but we could come get it. Meanwhile we had been faithful customers even after two bad experiences and spent so much money ordering pizzas with delivery in the past! Not to mention our needs as customers were not even considered; that we had been waiting an hour for dinner, the order was processed with no questions or concerns about location (because our information was in the system already) and the pizza was in the car!

1 Star Rating: Poor

03/06/09

Get it together

by CSMobileUser2 at Citysearch

Sisters used to be my favorite spot. Over the last few months they keep hitting new lows. Bad food, even worse service.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/04/09

??u tu brute?

by CSMobileUser at Citysearch

sisters pizza has been our family restaurant since it opened. i read there reviews and look down upon them. i have owned a pizza parlor and know the struggles they face. people don't realize what a dinner rush really is till you actually work a rush. its also first come first serve basis and still people don't understand what that means. these pizzas these guys make are hand made and the dough is not stretched like how they do it at pizza hut and other commercial places. great food takes time people and cannot just be thrown together and handed out like slop.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

11/11/08

I thought the pizza was good

by bing0bing0 at Citysearch

The place itself is very open and spacious. The staff was a bit unattentive. They didn't look busy at all for a Saturday night, so I wasn't sure why no one attempted to offer service. The pizza I ordered for my group was very delicious, however, it took over 30 minutes for it to arrive. I also placed an additional order for a slice of cheese pizza, and by the time it arrived to our table, we were done eating the whole pizza already. I recommend this place only if you don't have high expectations for service and if you have patience and time to hang out and wait for food. The food itself is very good, I definently think it would be a better experience if the customer service improved and if the time it takes to wait for the food was a bit faster.

  • Pros: Food
  • Cons: Customer service
1 Star Rating: Poor

09/24/08

We waited, and waited, and waited... and...

by FoodMan303 at Citysearch

Read the other reviews below and you'll understand. This is just another poorly run Steve Naples venture. We waited literally 40 minutes for two plates of ziti, which came to our table luke warm with sauce that tasted like it came out of a can. Asked for mushrooms which are usually cooked and for some reason they decided to throw them on raw this time. I'm usually pretty cool and would've been if the food had come out, oh, I dunno, say 30 minutes earlier. Next time I'll just pop open a can of Chef Boyardee and throw it in the microwave. Enter at your own risk.

  • Pros: Starbucks is next door. Grab a cup, wait 2 hours, come back and your food will be ready.
  • Cons: Might have to go through several cups of coffee at Starbucks waiting for food.
3 Star Rating: Average

07/09/08

First review, burned pizza

by ClaudiaLivingston at Citysearch

The linguini and mussels are to die for. There are days when only this dish will do. The pizza is the best I have ever eaten but twice now I have ordered a pizza, picked it up, drove it over to a friend's house and found it burned. Black on the bottom and I mean black. We ate half of it, what a shame. On the second occasion I had arrived early and was told to wait 5 to 10 minutes. I am thinking that the young lady forgot about it.

If I order another pizza, I will open the box and check it before I take it out.

Claudia Livingston

  • Pros: great linguini and mussels, great ambience
  • Cons: always new staff it seems, burned pizza. sluggish delivery service.
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/24/08

Yummy!

by lillyempire at Citysearch

I think this is one of those places where everything tastes good. The mussels are so yummy! And the pizza's are huge and very delicious!

I would reccommend anyone to this restaurant. We had excellent service and the guy that was fixing the pizza's was very entertaining and friendly. We did not have to wait very long at all.

Check it out and the White Wine Mussels are awesome!

3 Star Rating: Average

02/10/08

Really good food, really poor service

by kikigigi at Citysearch

The pie, mussels and salads are really good here. But these guys never have it together...it takes 10-15 minutes just to get a salad and a slice. I can see these guys doing their thing behind the counter but it seriously takes 10-15 to get a salad and a slice. The kicker is that this place is never busy!

Sisters is beyond fast food but still a casual dining restaurant...the food shouldn't take more than 5 minutes from the point of ordering to your table.

I just ordered delivery for the first time and after waiting 1:10 minutes (after they said 40 minutes), I had to say something about their poor service.

Showing 1-10 of 20 reviews

Advertisement
Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Sisters Pizza and Mussels

Sisters Pizza and Mussels

2255 Sheridan Blvd
Edgewater, CO 80214

Advertisement